Appeals
Committee Minutes
Thu Oct 16 2003Related Documents:
agenda for these minutes
Present :-
Councillors Mitchell (Chairman), Berman, Rawlinson, Mrs Taylor and Yabsley
*A/79 Minutes
RESOLVED that the minutes of the meeting held on 10 September 2003 be signed as a correct record.
*A/80 Exclusion of the Press and Public
RESOLVED that under Section 100A(4) of the Local Government Act 1972 the press and public be excluded from the meeting for the following item of business on the grounds that it involves the likely disclosure of exempt information as defined in Paragraph 5 of Part 1 of Schedule 12A of the Act, namely information relating to applicants for financial assistance from the County Council.
*A/81 Report on Route Inspection
(An item taken under Section 100A(4) of the Local Government Act 1972 during which the press and public were excluded).
The Director of Education, Arts and Libraries reported on the route inspection, Easternhill Farm to Doddiscombleigh. The route was considered to be available.
RESOLVED that the appeal for PE (3/62) be refused.
*A/82 Report on Deferred Cases
The Director of Education, Arts and Libraries reported on the deferred cases:
(a) JM (3/6) Newton Abbot to Heathfield, and
(b) ZR, ER & PR (3/64) Teignmouth to Dawlish.
The Committee considered the further evidence received in support of the appeals.
RESOLVED that the appeal for JM (3/6) be refused; and that the appeal for ZR only (3/64) be allowed
*A/83 School Transport Appeals
(An item taken under Section 100A(4) of the Local Government Act 1972 during which the press and public were excluded).
The Committee considered reports from the School Transport Team and written and verbal submissions from those appellants who attended, as follows:
| JK(3/117) | Torbryan to KEVICC | Mr K attended |
| JD & JD (3/111) | Ilfracombe to Braunton | Mr D attended |
| SW (3/122 | Kingsbridge to Dartmouth CC | No parent attended |
| RC & JC (3/112) | Lynton to Ilfracombe Berrynarbor to Ilfracombe | No parent attended |
| HF (3/99) | Yelverton to St Boniface 6th Form | Mr and Mrs F attended |
RESOLVED
(a) that the following appeals be allowed and the Committee exercise discretion to
provide free school transport or school transport assistance in respect of:
| JK(3/117) | Torbryan to KEVICC |
| HF (3/99) | Yelverton to St Boniface 6th Form |
(b) that the following appeals be refused:
| JD & JD (3/111) | Ilfracombe to Braunton |
| SW (3/122 | Kingsbridge to Dartmouth CC |
| RC & JC (3/112) | Lynton to Ilfracombe Berrynarbor to Ilfracombe |
*DENOTES DELEGATED MATTER WITH POWER TO ACT
The meeting started at 09.45am and finished at 1145am
APPEALS COMMITTEE
(At a meeting to consider East Area Appeals)
16 October 2003
Present:-
Councillors Mitchell (Chairman),Giles Lee, Nicholson and Rawlinson.
*A/83 Minutes
RESOLVED that the minutes of the meeting held on 10 September 2003 be signed as a correct record.
*A/84 Exclusion of the Press and Public
RESOLVED that under Section 100A(4) of the Local Government Act 1972 the press and public be excluded from the meeting for the following item of business on the grounds that it involves the likely disclosure of exempt information as defined in Paragraph 5 of Part 1 of Schedule 12A of the Act, namely information relating to applicants for financial assistance from the County Council.
*A/85 School Transport Appeals
The Committee considered reports from the School Transport Team and written and verbal submissions from those appellants who attended, as follows:
| LH (3/89) | Webble Green to Membury | Mrs H and Mr H (Snr)attended |
| PK (3/113) | Burnthouse Lane to St David's First School | Mrs M and CT social services attended |
| KB (3/119) | Alphington to Dawlish | Mr and Mrs B, Cllr Gale, Cllr Berman & Cllr Browning (ECC) |
| DK (3/123) | Haven Banks to St Peter's | No parent attended |
| PG & AG (3/100) | Exeter to Uffculme | No parent attended |
| GI (3/81) | Saint Hill to Uffculme | Mrs I and Mr G attended |
| SA (3/105) | Countesswear to Westexe | Mr A attended |
| JG & TG (3/ ) | Exeter to QECC | Mrs G attended |
| ST (3/101) | Willand to Uffculme | No parent attended |
| LL & CL (3/102) | Exeter to Westexe Exeter to John Stocker | No parent attended |
| GD (3/104) | Exwick to Stoke Hill | No parent attended |
| KT (3/109) | Burlescombe to Uffculme | No parent attended |
| SM (3/118) | Redhills to St James' | Mrs M attended |
RESOLVED
(a) that the following appeals be allowed and the Committee exercise discretion to
provide free school transport or school transport assistance in respect of:
| PK (3/113) | Burnthouse Lane to St David's First School |
| SA (3/105) | Countesswear to Westexe |
| JG & TG (3/ ) | Exeter to QECC |
| ST (3/101) | Willand to Uffculme |
| KT (3/109) | Burlescombe to Uffculme |
| SM (3/118) | Redhills to St James' |
(b) that the following appeals be refused:
| LH (3/89) | Webble Green to Membury |
| KB (3/119) | Alphington to Dawlish |
| DK (3/123) | Haven Banks to St Peter's |
| PG & AG (3/100) | Exeter to Uffculme |
| GD (3/104) | Exwick to Stoke Hill |
(c) that the following appeals be deferred to gather further information:
| LL & CL (3/102) | Exeter to Westexe Exeter to John Stocker |
(d) that the following appeal be deferred for a route inspection to be carried out.
| GI (3/81) | Saint Hill to Uffculme |
*DENOTES DELEGATED MATTER WITH POWER TO ACT
The meeting started at 1.00pm and finished at 4.30pm